incident at Rimstone River Cave

Date
6th Dec 1969
Publication
ACA 1967-1970 p. 31
Cave
Rimstone River Cave
State
Missouri
County
Unknown
Country
United States of America
Category
Cave
Incident type
Caver fall
Group type
Cavers
Group size
5
Aid type
Aid on standby
Source
Member of injured caver's party
Incident flags
     

Injured cavers

Name Age Sex Injuries Injured areas
Bennecke, Bob 20 Male Laceration Knee

Incident report

On 6 December Terry Pitchford (23), Ron Kistner (18), Gary Schaecher (22), Bob Bennecke (20) and Ron Bennecke (18) entered Rimstone River Cave at about 11 a.m. for the purpose of mapping an upstream side passage. The weather was cold with several inches of snow on the ground. Showers were forecast; this was taken into consideration as it was known that large portions of the cave flooded in heavy rains.

At about 2 p.m. the party reached the side passage (a mile in) and placed their inflatable boats about 40 feet above water. After surveying about 3000 feet of the passage, at 6:25 p.m., they noticed that the stream volume had increased considerably. While discussing whether or not they should head out or continue to survey, the water was observed to rise 4 inches. They decided to head farther in where the ceiling was high and large dry ledges could be found. Hurrying on, they encountered difficulty with high water, deep pools and falls. The water temperature had dropped to about 35°F.

At about 6:50 p.m. Bob Bennecke slipped and fell when a shale ledge broke. His knee cap was exposed and he bled profusely but the group continued on until they reached what appeared to be a safe area. Kistner and Ron Bennecke went on to look for a possible second entrance as passages in the area were known to be near the surface. Bob Bennecke's cut was bandaged. After the exploring party returned, unsuccessful, at about 1 a.m., it was decided that they should try to leave the cave: if they had not returned by 6 a.m., the remaining three would follow.

Pitchford, Schaecher and Bob Bennecke slept fitfully and then started out at 6 a.m. The last bit of passage prior to reaching the boat had only six inches of air space. The others had gone ahead. Near the entrance they had to climb a 35 foot ladder up through what had become a roaring torrent. They reached the surface at 11 a.m. Kistner and Ron Bennecke had contacted other cavers and a back-up crew was ready to start out if the three had not appeared by noon.

Source: Gary Schaecher

Incident analysis

(Schaecher) The cause of the accident was excessive speed in traversing a passage with tricky footing. The only possible preventative measure would have been a better respect for melting snow, which it turned out was the cause of the water rise. It was, of course, very fortunate that the injury did not incapacitate Bob Bennecke, necessitating his being carried. Plans have been made for placing survival kits in areas of the cave where teams may become trapped by high water. Also, stricter limits on trips into caves that flood will be set when weather conditions are poor.

This record was last updated on 27th Apr 2024 at 23:11 UTC.