incident at Brinegar

Date
22nd Dec 1980
Publication
ACA 1980-1981 p. 110
Cave
Brinegar
State
Indiana
County
Unknown
Country
United States of America
Category
Cave
Incident type
Stranded
Group type
Other
Group size
Unknown
Aid type
Unknown
Source
Unknown
Incident flags
 

Injured cavers

Name Age Sex Injuries Injured areas
Moring, John 23 Male Not recorded Not recorded

Incident report

On Monday, December 22, brothers John (23) and David (19) Moring from Cincinnati, Ohio, went exploring in Brinegar Cave near Bloomington, Indiana. The elder brother had not been caving before, but the younger had gotten experience while an explorer scout. At around noon they left their station wagon at the end of Eller Road on the edge of Blenz's property (NSS Cave Files). They had two helmets, a carbide lamp, an electric headlamp, an electric hand lantern and some rope, but took only the carbide lamp, one helmet, and the rope into the cave. When their light failed sometime later they became stranded. The cavers were expected home on Monday evening and their parents apparently called the police and eventually, on Wednesday, a Cincinnati caver, Tom Gracinin was called for help. He called Blenz's place where cavers usually register before caving and relayed the info on the cavers and their equipment. Pat Ennis was there and called Don Paquette. Others were put on standby while Paquette checked the car. At about 5:30 p.m. he broke into the car and came to realize the lost cavers had only one light with them. He returned to Blenz's and put a search in progress. At 7 p.m. other cavers arrived and checked the entrances to Wayne's, Shaft, Grotto and Coons Caves. At 7:45 Paquette called Tom Rea in Indianapolis to put the Central Indiana Grotto on standby. At around 9 p.m. the search party returned having found nothing. Other cavers who had logged in at Blenz's on trips that week were called without results. At 10 p.m. several cavers checked Buckners. Lee Noon was called and a warm gas body warming system was put on standby to be flown in if needed. Hypothermia was a concern. Travel time for the system would be two hours. At 1 a.m. Thursday, the Indianapolis stand-by group was called in. Three cavers headed for Brinegar's at 2 a.m. with a more thorough search planned when more manpower arrived. The lost cavers were found in the entrance stream passage in the pits just after the crevice. They were in good shape so their rescuers recharged their lamp and they were escorted out arriving at Blenz's at 3:15 a.m.

Incident analysis

Brinegar is not a cold cave so hypothermia was not a problem. Also, there was water in the cave which the lost cavers apparently made use of. The main theme here is the recurring one of non-organized cavers going caving ill-prepared. If they had left a note giving their objective on their car it would have made their rescue much simpler.

References

  1. 1) Barbara Mogenstern "Two Brothers Lost in Cave Found Safe After Two Day Search" Cincinnati Post December 26, 1980.
  2. 2) Dick Blenz Personal Communication June 1, 1981.
  3. 3) Don Paquette And to All, A Good Night!" BIG Newsletter 16:2 p 20-21.
This record was last updated on 29th Apr 2024 at 20:27 UTC.